You asked, they answered: 'Battlestar Galactica' writers take on your 'No Exit' questions

You asked, they answered: 'Battlestar Galactica' writers take on your 'No Exit' questions

Last Friday, after the episode titled "No Exit" aired, I posted some thoughts on it, and in the comment area of that post, "Battlestar Galactica" fans got a chance to ask questions of "Battlestar" writers Jane Espenson and Ryan Mottesheard.

I culled a group of questions from the long list of excellent queries posed by fans (and I threw in a few of my own questions). Below, Ryan and Jane kindly answer those questions. Note that some questions have been rephrased or reframed a bit.

If you want links to a series of interviews with "Battlestar" writers about the first four episodes of Season 4.5, you'll find those links here. All my previous "Battlestar" coverage is here.

OK, on to Ryan and Jane's answers.

Mo: Did the amount ofinformation that you needed to convey in "No Exit" make it particularlychallenging to write? Was it more or less challenging than a typical"Battlestar" assignment?

Jane: Much more challenging.  That's one of the reasons it took so many of usto write it.  First, Ron wrote the Cavil/Ellen material, then Ryan didthe hardest work --writing the draft on which we all built.  DavidWeddle and Bradley Thompson polished it, which added some new elements, and thenI took a final pass through it.  Both stories in the episode were verydifficult to write, because they both required finding interesting waysto convey massive amounts of information.  Luckily, this wasn't justinformation that we wanted the audience to have, it was informationthat the audience wanted to have.

Mo: Was Kobol the original origin point for humanity, or was it Earth?

Jane: I've always taken it to be Kobol. 

Mo: Why was Earth destroyed?

Jane: The skinjob-style Cylons on Earth built their own metal battlebots who turned on them.

Mo: What was it like working with John Hodgman? Was Dr. Gerard written tobe a bit of comic relief or was that what John naturally brought to therole?

Jane: Dr. Gerard was a role we wrote specifically for John Hodgman.  He wasintended to be a slightly heightened and amusing character, and hispitch-perfect performance helped us get the right tone.

Mo: Was there a lot that had to be cut from this episode?

Jane: There was certainly material that was cut.  I recall that Ellen saidmore to Boomer in that exchange in which she ate the apple.  And therewas a much longer and more elaborate escape sequence that got graduallywhittled down all during pre-production, and then during production,and which ended up going away entirely by the end of it all.

Mo: What was it like shooting the episode -- did anything go better thanyou thought it would? Worse? Any memorable anecdotes from the set?

Jane: The Anders material worked so much better than I'd feared.  MichaelTrucco gave it such urgency and weight that it never dragged, even whenthe amount of information was so daunting on the page.  I was reallyblown away by his performance in this episode. 

Ryan: I have to give major props to Michael Trucco.  He came in soooo prepared and infused that performance, which is, let’s face, burdened with a huge amount of information to spill out, with an extra layer of spooky transcendence.

[Many readers asked various versions of this question] How did Saul Tigh know Adama for such a long time?

Jane: They didn't meet until after the war.  Saul was given false memories and introduced into life among humans at that point.

Leah: One of the things that's been interesting about the show is the way you follow a character very closely for a time, so that we feel we get some knowledge of his/her inner life, and then pull back, so that we see that person mostly from the outside, and have to work to extrapolate emotional/psychological state entirely from action. Boomer is a prime example of this--we used to be so close to her that I've been really curious about her inner life ever since we got our last real glimpse of it in "Downloaded." How much do you talk about what's happening with characters that we might not see onscreen?What do you know about Boomer that we don't? 

Ryan: We mapped out exactly what we had seen of Boomer since “Downloaded”â€"seeing her on the baseship ready to snap Hera’s neck, etc.â€"and made sure it tracked with what we were seeing over 18 months in this episode.  After we saw her defect to Cavil’s baseship (“Six of One”) she committed herself, perhaps more than any other Cylon, to following Cavil’s quest to become the most perfect machine possible.

Jane: Keep watching.  More Boomer comin' at'cha.

Jeremy L: How much of what is happening now  was known to the writers during Season 1, during Season 2, etc? Conversely, I would imagine that going in to the final 10 episodes that there is some sort of outline. How much of "No Exit" was provided in that outline and how much had to be fleshed out in developing the specific episode?

Ryan: Initially, much of the action in “No Exit” was designed to play through a few episodes.  However, as the Cavil/Ellen story takes place over the course of 18 months since Ellen’s death on New Caprica, the intercutting between base ship past and Galactica present started to get confusing and we felt that distilling into one episode would be the best approach.

Jane: We certainly knew the details that were laid out in "No Exit" as weentered the final half-season.  The general shape of it was known to usbefore that, with things slotting into place here and there throughout,many of them before I joined the show in season four.  I can't speak towhat was known in season one or two.

Greg: How come Ellen and Anders knew Daniel but none of the other [Colonialskinjobs aside from] John/Cavil know any of the Final Five?

Ryan: Ellen knows of Daniel because she is the only one of the Final Five who died and thus, had her original memories restored.  The idea being that Cavil wiped their memories when he gassed them and sent them to live amongst the humans on Earth.  As for Anders, that knowledge comes from getting shot in the head and the bullet moving through his head is tapping into those repressed memories.

John/Cavil is the only one who knows the Final Five because he corrupted the programming of the other six models to never speak of the Final Five or search for their identities.  Obviously, if they did, then his little house of cards topples, which is why he boxed D’Anna.

Jane: Ellen regained her memories when she downloaded, and Anders got hiswhen he was shot in the head.  All the other Cylons memories of theFinal Five were erased by Cavil.

Don C: Could you please provide dates for when:
A) the Thirteenth Tribe (of Cylons) left Kobol
B) the Twelve Tribes (of humans) left Kobol
C) Pythia lived and wrote her scrolls.

Jane: The dates and sequence of the events surrounded Pythia and Kobol aregoing to be explored, I understand, in a comic book being written bySeamus Kevin Fahey [who is a "Battlestar" writer] and David Reed.

Marc: If the Centurions' contempt and hatred for the Colonials is sogreat that they started a war to annihilate them, then why were they soeager to create skin jobs? Why did they want to "evolve" into thatwhich they hated?

Jane: Ahhh.  I LOVE this question.  To me, it's not a plot question, but a psychology question. Why do even people who dislike their parents still choose paths thatturn them into their parents?  Why would slaves willingly take on theproperties of their (weak and limited) former masters?  Why do thosewho rebel against dictators become dictators themselves?  I hope my jobisn't to answer the question, because I don't have the answer, but Ilove looking at the question.

Ryan: Do you think Six would’ve been able to weasel her way into Baltar’s mainframe if she looked more like a Centurion than Tricia Helfer?  There are definite advantages to taking on the guise of your enemy.

Dave B: I don't understand Cavil's anger in the sense that he blamesthe Final Five for his human form. But according to Anders this waswhat the Centurions wanted. Shouldn't Cavil be directing his anger atthem?

Jane: Parents work hard to get their child admitted to a prestigious school. The child hates the school and ultimately decides that attending thatschool put him on a path that ruined the rest of his life.  Does heblame the culture that let his parents to prefer that school?  Does heblame all the other children who love the school?   Does he blame theschool?  Well, yeah, probably that one, but mostly he blames hisparents.  Especially if what he's really feeling is a terrible fearthat he disappointed his parents by not excelling.

Ryan: The Centurions didn’t create Cavil.  The Final Five did.  We saw the Centurions experimenting with Hybrids during ‘Razor’ and we also saw the Final Five as ‘skin jobs’ on Kobol thousands of years ago, so I don’t think the idea of aspiring to human form is all that surprising.  (I kinda get the feeling that Cavil wouldn’t have been content in a metal body either, don’t you?)

Oscar R: What kind of relationship will the story of "Caprica" havewith the story of "Battlestar Galactica"? Without getting intospoilers, will we need to watch "Caprica" to understand "BSG's" story,or will "Caprica" be more of a self contained story within the mythology of "BSG"?

Jane: Oh!  Interesting.  Usually people ask that question the other wayaround.  Of course, the answer is the same either way: you don't needto know either show to fully enjoy and understand the other show.  Novital pieces of "BSG" will be left unsatisfied so that we can tackle themon "Caprica," unless you feel incomplete without knowing the full andexciting story of the origin of Caprica's Centurions -- WHICH YOUSHOULD, of course.

James: One thing I would like to know is if the Final Five (and therest of the Earth Cylons) believed in the One True God like theCenturions do?

Jane: The Final Five were polytheists until they met the Centurions, who were monotheists.

Carl: Since this episode contained so much information and backstory,I'm interested to hear from Ryan and Jane about the lack of flashbacksto Earth despite it being so central to the Cylon story. The vastmajority of the information is revealed mostly with Sam as a sort ofstoryteller to the others. Was it a conscious choice to not cutaway toscenes of the actual creation of the eight models? Budget reasons?

Jane: The idea of using flashbacks was discussed and decided against.  Idon't recall if I heard the reasoning behind doing it this way, but Ilike how it plays in the finished episode.  Without the flashbacks, theviewers can watch the information as it hits the listeners.  Since theemotional heart of the episode is in those reactions, I think you'dmiss them.

Ryan: Budget concerns would probably have reared their ugly head at some point, but there was a general feeling that the audience should experience these revelations as Tigh, Tory and Tyrol do, with Anders telling them and without cutting away to omniscient flashbacks.  Further, I don’t think it’s a stretch to imagine what these scenes would’ve been and to paraphrase the estimable David Cronenberg, "if you know what the scene is, then you don’t need to see it."

Ein Staunender: Will we get more information about this [previously]unknown colony [mentioned by Cavil in one of his conversations withEllen]? Is it possibly founded or inhabited by people from earth? Ordescendants/incarnations of the Final Five?

Jane: Oh, you mean The Colony?  You're assuming it's a colony?

Clifton: What does Ellen resurrect into when she dies on New Caprica? Are we supposed to infer that there are other copies of the [Final Five], just as with the seven (nee, eight) [other] models?

Ryan: Yes, you should infer that if Tigh, Tyrol, Anders or Tory died somewhere along the line, a body would’ve been waiting for them on Cavil’s baseship.  That they all survived the Cylon attack from the miniseries and countless travails and Cylon attacks since and that Ellen’s death only came at the hand of a fellow Final Fiver Is pretty remarkable… and infinitely infuriating to Cavil, I would imagine.

Max Bell: Ryan, that was frakking AWESOME. Correct me if I'm mistaken, but IMDB and BSGWiki both show this as being your first script, yes? As complicated as this episode was, did your work as script coordinator give you an edge in keeping all this straight?

Ryan: Script coordinator, like writers' assistant, is a job usually held by aspiring writers.  While not creative in and of itself, you are working closely with the writing staff and reading every outline and every draft of every script along the way.  I definitely knew the "BSG" universe, but had to tap the entire staff’s collective brain throughout the development process, a process which is extremely collaborative to being with.

Chris: Given that [the "Battlestar Galactica" movie] "The Plan" isforthcoming (I'm looking at you, Jane), am I to assume that perhaps notall of our Cylon history questions will be fully answered by the end ofthe series? And Jane, when you have the time, will you please start blogging again? I am one of your gentle readers and I miss you terribly.

Jane: There will certainly be questions that get answered in "The Plan," butnot in such a way that the end of "BSG" will feel incomplete.  And I hopeto reblog someday.  Right now I'm incredibly busy as we're beginningthe work of crafting the stories for Caprica, but I'm learning so muchthrough the process that I feel like I'm refilling my blogtank.

Richard S.: Question for Jane:  “No Exit” gave the viewers a fairlydetailed exposition of Cylon history and it sounds as if John/Cavil mayhave had a greater hand in setting up the Galactica for survival, or atleast pointing Ellen Tigh and the rest of the Final Five in the rightdirection to view humanity “at its worst”.  Did we as viewers just geta synopsis for "The Plan” in “No Exit”, in much the same way “Pegasus”served as a synopsis for the events depicted in “Razor”?  It sounds tome that the Cylon plan… or at least Cavil’s plan was to teach theirparents (the Final Five) a lesson.

Jane: Hmm... I hadn't thought of it that way, but I like it.

Carla: Who or what, then, is Starbuck?

Ryan: Do you really want to me to answer that with five episodes to go?  C’mon… tune in next week.

Lori C: The only [moment] in "No Exit" that gave me pause was when Adama refused
Chief's offer of Cylon technology to fix Galactica.  After all, Adamawas the one pushing for the installation of Cylon FTLs throughout the fleet, leading to the mutiny which just ended.  Why was he so hesitant,especially with Galactica in such dire shape?

Jane: This is about replacing the very bones of Galactica.  About her notbeing her anymore, about Adama being forced to acknowledge the diseasethat's taking her away.  It's about turning to the Cylons not just tohelp us but to make us and them the same.  I see it as being an orderof magnitude beyond the earlier decision. 

Ryan:  On some level, Adama is owning up to his responsibility for the mutiny â€" what was Lee’s line in The Oath about Zarek being right? â€" and is therefore reluctant to forge a deeper reliance on Cylon tech after the devastation it wrought.  (Laura too, acknowledges her own responsibility by passing the baton to Lee.)  Further, Adama is unwilling to accept that Galactica is in as bad shape as Tyrol says and his story in this episode is about him finally facing that fact.

Justin: One thing that I wished was addressed in last night's episode, and wasn't, was the fate of the mutineers other than Gaeta and Zarek. What happened to Racetrack, Narcho, and Seelix?

Ryan: Mr. Angeli addressed this point quite subtly (and definitively) I thought in the previous episode when we saw Kelly flip-flop and Adama offer mutineers the opportunity to recommit their allegiances during his final march towards CIC.

Minimalism to the max in Philip Glass's 4-hour 'Music in Twelve Parts'
Some people might find the prospect of listening to Philip Glass's 'Music in Twelve Parts' '” a more than three-hour marathon of rapidly pin-wheeling melodic and rhythmic figures composed in the early '70s '” to be disagreeable, laughable or even torturous. As a listener who has experienced depression and maybe even something closer to brain death while listening to certain Glass pieces, which can seem to be composed by the yard, I understand the fear. Yet with regard to 'Music in Twelve Parts,' my suggestion is to think again.
The Curious Face Of Benjamin Button

The Curious Case of Benjamin Button has earned 13 Oscar nominations, including a nod for special effects and another for best actor — two categories that are uniquely reliant upon each other in this particular film.

BOOKS: Was Bush Doctrine Just a Little Bit of History Repeating?
NEW YORK, Feb 16 (IPS)Was the foreign policy of George W. Bush an aberration in U.S. history, a turn away from the traditional guiding principles of U.S. foreign policy towards messianic ambitions of permanent supremacy and universal democracy?